Скачать с ютуб Canoe vs. Kayak - Which is Better? | Mississagi River Whitewater Paddling | Part 3 в хорошем качестве

Canoe vs. Kayak - Which is Better? | Mississagi River Whitewater Paddling | Part 3

In Part 3 of our Mississagi River adventure, I'm tackling a debate that's sparked discussions among outdoor enthusiasts for years: Which is better for a river adventure like this, the canoe or the kayak? Join me as we journey 28 km (17 miles) down some of the Mississagi River's many swifts and rapids to find out. Introduction To settle this, I've chosen six categories to compare: Storage, Speed, Portaging, Maneuverability, Stability, and Comfort. Storage I've done a few camping trips using kayaks, and despite their narrow shape, the amount of gear you can pack inside still surprises me. The key is to use smaller, squishy dry bags that can be stuffed into the kayak's nooks and crannies. On the other hand, packing a canoe is much more forgiving. Large dry bags or even plastic bins fit easily inside. When it comes to payload capacity, I suspect a canoe will usually win over a kayak of the same length. Speed I've never raced a canoe against a kayak, but I suspect a single-person kayak would generally outpace a single-person canoe. The double-bladed kayak paddle likely gives the kayak an edge, although there's no rule against using one in a canoe. From my experience, for the average recreational paddler, the kayak has the advantage in flat-water speed. Portaging I've portaged a few canoes in my time, and while it's not fun, it's manageable. Portaging a kayak, on the other hand, can be a struggle—sometimes, I even need a cart to help. In my experience, the canoe wins hands down when it comes to moving it around on shore. Maneuverability This was my first time paddling a kayak through swifts and small rapids, and I found it extremely maneuverable compared to my experiences in a canoe. However, I've mostly paddled tandem canoes, which involve a team element, so the comparison might not be entirely fair. Because you're sitting up higher in a canoe than a kayak, I find spotting underwater rocks a lot easier from a canoe, but when it's time to make a sudden maneuver, I think the kayak is more responsive. Stability Speaking of being higher up, let's talk about stability. I find a canoe to be less stable than a kayak in certain situations, largely due to the higher center of gravity from sitting on a seat that's much higher than in a kayak. Of course, hull shape plays a big role here, and my kayak is designed for stability, not speed. Despite occasionally being sideways to the river's current on the Mississagi, I never felt at risk of tipping over. While narrow-hulled sea kayaks can be quite tippy—I've flipped in them, and in canoes too—for this kayak and my Grumman canoe, I'd give the nod to the kayak for stability due to its hull shape and low center of gravity Comfort Finally, let's talk about comfort. This one is more subjective. I'm more comfortable in a kayak, but my wife and many friends prefer the roominess and freedom of movement in a canoe. My kayak has a large cockpit and a wide hull, making it more like a canoe in that regard, so I guess the canoe wins this round. Conclusion Other factors like wind, water conditions, and trip length could also influence your choice. Ultimately, it boils down to personal preference. If you weren't keeping score, here's the summary: for comfort, carrying capacity, and ease of portaging, the canoe is the better choice. For speed, maneuverability, and stability, the kayak comes out on top—at least in my experience. If you have any thoughts, I'd love to hear them in the comments. Thanks for watching, and I hope you enjoyed the ride on the Mississagi! If you like this kind of content, please like and subscribe. Thanks! #KayakVsCanoe, #MississagiRiver, #RiverAdventure, #KayakCamping, #CanoeCamping, #OutdoorAdventure, #Paddling, #KayakLife, #CanoeLife, #PaddleComparison, #CanoeVsKayak, #KayakingTrip, #CanoeingTrip, #AdventureAwaits, #KayakExploration, #CanoeJourney, #RiverPaddling, #KayakManoeuvrability, #CanoeStability, #Portaging, #OutdoorExploration, #PaddleOn, #DiscoverAlgoma, #AlgomaWilderness, #BeautifulAlgoma, #ExploreAlgoma, #AlgomaNature Gear: Akaso Brave 7 and/or DJI Osmo Pocket DJI Mini 2 Hohem iSteady Gimbal Pelican 10' Kayak and/or Riot Bayside 12 HV (High Volume) Kayak Harmony Sea Passage Paddle Salus PFD